Post by Jenya on Jun 20, 2009 14:40:17 GMT -5
Ok, so I don't think Amelia is a spy but I'll wait to post my reasoning til after Imprisonment. Don't want to make myself a target!
If Amelia is a Spy, then she and the other two Spies aren't very bright. In fact, they're utterly clueless.
Amelia posted at 5:50PM Monday that she'd gotten Imprisonment Immunity from Iris. This is after Rey, Boris, Kirsten, Thor, Ellis and Jenya called bullshit on Iris in the "Talking about roles" thread and Ariel defended Iris in that thread.
If Amelia is a Spy, it's nearly incomprehensible that no spy had contacted her before she made this post admitting that she got an Imprisonment Immunity from Iris. For the sake of argument, assume that if Amelia is a spy, she was contacted by a spy before she made that post.
The Spies had to be discussing options, knowing Iris was screwed. Would they tell their spypartner Amelia:
1) Help Iris confirm her role, even though she's probably going down anyway and will drag Amelia with her.
2) Deny, deny, deny. Amelia should cheer triumphantly that she's 100% positive Iris is a spy because she's lying.
Remember, this is not just Amelia making this judgment call. Iris and two other spies are running around fervently, thinking up the best way to take a Citizen or two down with Iris. Here's how various people have been playing the Iris situation:
* Kirsten demolished her with a post, and jumped on Amelia preemptively.
* Rey "interviewed" Iris and made himself look like the person who exposed her lie.
* Ariel was defending Iris until it was untenable, then switched sides.
* Boris was attacking Iris from the moment she claimed.
* Thor attacked Iris from the moment she claimed.
* Georgia attacked Iris from the moment she claimed.
* William attacked Iris right after Amelia's post.
* Tibby apologized to Faith and went AFK.
* Pete was absent Monday.
* Mirela launched a massive attack on Iris, albeit later.
So there's definitely a spy or two in that batch.. why would all the other spies be attacking Iris while Amelia's just playing along dumbly?
Maybe she's just a terrible spy, I dunno.
If Amelia is a Spy, then she and the other two Spies aren't very bright. In fact, they're utterly clueless.
Amelia posted at 5:50PM Monday that she'd gotten Imprisonment Immunity from Iris. This is after Rey, Boris, Kirsten, Thor, Ellis and Jenya called bullshit on Iris in the "Talking about roles" thread and Ariel defended Iris in that thread.
If Amelia is a Spy, it's nearly incomprehensible that no spy had contacted her before she made this post admitting that she got an Imprisonment Immunity from Iris. For the sake of argument, assume that if Amelia is a spy, she was contacted by a spy before she made that post.
The Spies had to be discussing options, knowing Iris was screwed. Would they tell their spypartner Amelia:
1) Help Iris confirm her role, even though she's probably going down anyway and will drag Amelia with her.
2) Deny, deny, deny. Amelia should cheer triumphantly that she's 100% positive Iris is a spy because she's lying.
Remember, this is not just Amelia making this judgment call. Iris and two other spies are running around fervently, thinking up the best way to take a Citizen or two down with Iris. Here's how various people have been playing the Iris situation:
* Kirsten demolished her with a post, and jumped on Amelia preemptively.
* Rey "interviewed" Iris and made himself look like the person who exposed her lie.
* Ariel was defending Iris until it was untenable, then switched sides.
* Boris was attacking Iris from the moment she claimed.
* Thor attacked Iris from the moment she claimed.
* Georgia attacked Iris from the moment she claimed.
* William attacked Iris right after Amelia's post.
* Tibby apologized to Faith and went AFK.
* Pete was absent Monday.
* Mirela launched a massive attack on Iris, albeit later.
So there's definitely a spy or two in that batch.. why would all the other spies be attacking Iris while Amelia's just playing along dumbly?
Maybe she's just a terrible spy, I dunno.