Post by Pete on May 27, 2009 15:22:09 GMT -5
Ok guys, I had a spare ten minutes, I thought I would go through the roles that were suggested for his contest and logically cross out those that are
a) stupid
b) very stupid
c) overpowered
d) so stupid I cant believe someone actually suggested it
e) logically could not be
EGOIST - Though I never like the idea of shopping for goods that you get by doing some minial task in mafia games....this one is not too overpowered and not idiotic. It basically forces the person to get people to talk about them in the game, I think if it was used it would be heavely edited or it would too easily give away who the spies are. However, it is equally obvious that a girl wrote this, or someone planning to play a girl in the game, as such, if this was used, a girl has it.
BARTENDER - Spy role so obviously cannot be in the game.
GOON - Spy role
MACHINE OPERATOR - Very overpowered, but it has some potential as a role, so if it is in the game, it will have been edited.
LIGHT SWITCH OPERATOR - That is my one, so it cannot be in the game.
FOREMAN - Whoever wrote this has a superman complex or something.
JOKER - Just plain stupid, this guy must have played a few weird games of mafia and thinks this is a stroke of pure genius.
LOVERS - STTTTTUUUPPIIIIDDDDD, but it is third party, and it was implied there will be a few of them, so who knows.
NINJAS - Why do people post such drivvle?
POLITICIAN - Moving on...
LAWYER - I dont get the impression that this is a role that Sam would use, and whoever wrote this did so because they wanted a get out of jail free card. No.
FACTORY SOCIAL COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSON - Note the chairPERSON, I get the impression that if this role is in play and if someone has it, it will be Yvette.
TWIN SYMPS - I cant rule this one out, as weird as it may be, because it would actually fit in somewhat with the evidence we have on Paris and his role, maybe called something slightly different?
TASKMASTER - NO, Swapping roles? What kind of a role is that, what kind of information can that possibly provide?
SCAB - Ooooh, I recommend people read this one, this could occur, Im not sure the kind of information that can be extracted from it, but, it could be in the game....Maybe.
COMDEMNED - Sorry mate, but since when are we playing vampires? Similarily why do you think it is acceptable to allow the spies two imprisonments per round. Stupid and stupid.
a) stupid
b) very stupid
c) overpowered
d) so stupid I cant believe someone actually suggested it
e) logically could not be
EGOIST - Though I never like the idea of shopping for goods that you get by doing some minial task in mafia games....this one is not too overpowered and not idiotic. It basically forces the person to get people to talk about them in the game, I think if it was used it would be heavely edited or it would too easily give away who the spies are. However, it is equally obvious that a girl wrote this, or someone planning to play a girl in the game, as such, if this was used, a girl has it.
MACHINE OPERATOR - Very overpowered, but it has some potential as a role, so if it is in the game, it will have been edited.
FACTORY SOCIAL COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSON - Note the chairPERSON, I get the impression that if this role is in play and if someone has it, it will be Yvette.
TWIN SYMPS - I cant rule this one out, as weird as it may be, because it would actually fit in somewhat with the evidence we have on Paris and his role, maybe called something slightly different?
SCAB - Ooooh, I recommend people read this one, this could occur, Im not sure the kind of information that can be extracted from it, but, it could be in the game....Maybe.
And yeah, my Joker and Two-Face roles were genius... 
